Implied Dissent

Sunday, June 26, 2011

The Right Tool, at the Wrong Time

(Background to let you know what this is about here, here, and here).
I can prove that Greg Mankiw is a better economist than is Paul Krugman. How? Well, Paul is something like 5'6", and Mankiw is 6'2". Therefore, anyone claiming otherwise is selling voodoo.
What's that you say? You think that that's not a good way to show what I want to show? Well, you must be pretending to be stupid. I mean, NBA scouts use height to judge prospects. And height has a lot to do with a man's attractiveness.
True, height doesn't have much correlation to economic knowledge or wisdom. So? Krugman's economic brilliance must be puny if he's not even close to Mankiw in height.

Labels: , ,

Friday, May 20, 2011

(Implicitly) Making Stuff (Up)

This is a pet peeve of mine, but I think it's important (so maybe pet peeve isn't the right term). Paul Krugman wrote a column on the state of US manufacturing, and can't find two sentences to note that the idea of long term decline is a myth. Not only that, but he very carefully constructs his sentences to leave the impression on people that it's true, without actually lying that I can see. Check out the data, while US manufacturing does dip a little during recessions, it is clearly rising over time. It's one thing when some random pundit without much economics knowledge doesn't know this stuff, but Krugman either does, or absolutely should. Chances of DeLong noting this? Approximately 0.1%.

Labels: , ,

Friday, April 15, 2011

Alright then

Well, Obama has joined the debate. A bit demagogue-y, but still. My preliminary read on it is that his plan is about 85% serious, so a step up from Ryan's in that respect. Of course Krugman's reaction is to gloss over all of his unserious maneuvers that mirror Ryan's. $3T in unspecified deduction eliminations? Completely ridiculous. $1T? Well done.
On the Medicare part of it, I find the plan terrible. Serious, I suppose, but terrible. Have we not learned that central planning is unworkable? However, here is a compromise plan I think would actually work, giving people pining for socialized medicine what they're looking for, and people looking for more individual choice what we're looking for. Well done, Tyler.

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Paul Ryan

I partially agree with Krugman's assessment of Paul Ryan's budget plan. The growth assumptions look aggressive, and many key parts of it are...unspecified. However, I do have some disagreements as well.
Krugman says that anyone who didn't regard his original blueprint for the proposal as unserious has no credibility. What were the reasons to regard it as unserious? That the CBO hadn't evaluated the tax part of it. Which it hadn't done because it was swamped with Obamacare. And...that seems to be all of it. Now, that he still hasn't had CBO score it is bad, but complaining about it at that time would be like complaining that I hadn't proven my senior thesis at the time that I was proposing it, or calling a batter out for not touching home plate after a home run, when he was still making his way to first base.
On Medicare, again, the assumptions look aggressive. However, Krugman's key complaint is that the spending cuts won't actually be allowed to go through once they would start to take effect in many years. And he may be right; I too am pessimistic about the likelihood of large spending cuts. But then, Medicare as it is currently plotted will definitely not be allowed happen, it's much too generous. You punch through your target (especially when your growth assumptions are too rosy).
Lastly, many people are complaining that he doesn't touch military spending. This is simply untrue. As you can see here, the part of the budget that includes defense spending in his plan is currently at 12% of GDP, and his plan cuts that to 3.5%. Defense spending right now is about 6%. No way to do that without cuts to the military, or very high growth in the economy.
All in all, I'd call his plan about 75% serious. Which makes it about 75% more serious than anything I see coming from the other side of the aisle.
UPDATE: I've looked more closely at the economic growth projections, and they actually look a lot more reasonable than I thought. The unemployment rate is ridiculous, but the GDP growth numbers are not outrageous at all. Not saying I trust Heritage, but how these numbers feed into deficit projections aren't a big strike against it or the plan.

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Oh

Wow, I can't believe it didn't see it before. Clearly people who have problems with federal spending on infrastructure are racists, if not outright pro-slavery.

Labels: ,

Thursday, June 17, 2010

Finally

Krugman admits that fiscal stimulus (the guv spending money) is an ineffectual way to increase GDP. I'm sure that he doesn't realize that he did this, but it's the clear implication.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, May 18, 2010

Robustitude

Krugman blogged what he sees as the Nth reason libertarianism doesn't work (no hints as to what A thru M are, nor if part O is forthcoming). Various bloggers respond negatively (here, here, and here, for instance). I have to say, though, Paul's right. Libertarians (at least the vast majority) are in favor of the government; we want much less of it than other people, but libs still support the institution. Every institution requires good people in decision-making positions (we'll interpret Paul's "incorruptible" as "honest" or the like). I guess what Paul misses is that shrinking an institution's role reduces the damage that comes from having not-so-good people in charge of it; conversely, expanding an institution makes the damage that comes from having those people in charge much worse. As a negative bonus, bad people tend to be attracted to more powerful institutions. Libertarianism is far more robust to the inevitable occurrence of bad people in positions of power than is big government

Labels: , ,

Sunday, May 02, 2010

ID Reloaded

Getting back into it, with some quick hits:
On Arizona's illegal immigration bill, this is just about right.
On a related note, when dealing with the police, know your rights and how to defend them.
Sowell on the limits of power, examining the ultimate case. Whatever problems I have with him on foreign policy (largely because he doesn't apply his domestic/economic thinking consistently there), he almost always spot on with this kind of stuff.
Shorter Paul Krugman: When Democrats are in favor of something, it's because they're good people. When Democrats are against something, it's because they're good people. When Republicans are for something, it's because they're bad people. When Republicans are against something, it's because they're bad people. Glad we got that straight.

Labels: , , , ,

Sunday, November 08, 2009

If B, then B

This takes question begging to a whole new level. Usually people just implicitly assume their conclusions. Here Krugman does it explicitly. He starts with the assumption that P is fixed. Then examines what would happen under a given policy and finds that P doesn't change. Wow. Very impressive.
Update: See this Sumner post on this as well. Really hoists Krugman by his own petard. You might say that Krugman is petarded.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, November 04, 2009

Taking a step back

I probably overdid it with that last post. That's how you know he's probably lying or misleading. It's not 100%.
Also, a dolphin learns to save, invest, and speculate. Woh.

Labels: , , ,

Monday, November 02, 2009

Shorter Mankiw

How do you tell when Krugman is lying? Either his lips are moving or he's typing.
BTW, did anyone else catch Geithner saying on Meet the Press that the number of jobs saved by the stimulus is a fact? Really Timmy? A fact? I accept that it's your best guess at the effect, that the estimate was made in good faith, etc. But it is by no means a fact. It's an estimate based on some models. No more, no less.

Labels: , ,

Friday, July 31, 2009

Good Point

Mankiw links to Krugman on why HMOs don't work particularly well. I think they're both right. Krugman is right to distrust HMOs, and Mankiw is right to distrust giving government that much direct power over his (and my) health. However, the whole weight of history supports the idea that we can't trust government, while only a few decades support the idea that HMOs are bad. Like a rational Russian in 1918, I'd be against the Czar and actively oppose the Lenin, and today I'm against HMOs and am actively against having even more government control over healthcare.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, July 29, 2009

Lies about Honesty

More Krugman. He calls out Feldstein for mistakes in a piece. I agree that Feldstein should admit his errors. However, Krugman ends by saying "if I misstated the facts like this in the Times, I’d be required to publish a correction". Really? How about if he claimed in a column that Herbert Hoover cut government spending during the Great Depression?
(added link to my original post on the column)

Labels: , ,

Monday, July 27, 2009

My god, he broke the code

Paul Krugman comes to the realization that some people oppose initiatives that give the government more power. His powers of analysis truly are limitless.

Labels: , ,

Friday, February 13, 2009

Krugman Watch

Just a couple of points here. Krugman calls out Republican irresponsibility. Fair enough, Republicans are probably the only people more irresponsible than Democrats. However, he quotes Arnold Kling comparing the administration's plans to thugs breaking into his house. One problem, Kling is no Republican. Actually, two problems, as Kling also (first) compared the Bush administration to thugs. Hardly being a Republican hack. [Update: Video and partial transcript of what was said. Shockingly, The NY Times didn't fact-check Krugman one little bit.]
One other thing. It may seem like semantics, but I think it's important. Krugman claims the administration's stimulus plan will cost less than Bush's tax cuts. Sorry, but no. Taxes are costs, tax cuts are not. To spend is to tax. Therefore, a real tax cut cannot cost more than spending. Fake tax cuts can (like rebate checks), but I'm pretty sure those were small enough to keep the cost of Bush's tax cuts below this monstrosity that Obama wants. [I want to emphasize here that I'm not a fan of Bush's tax cuts for a few reasons, but I believe that how we use the word cost to describe government actions needs to be correct so that we think about them correctly, or at least better.]

Labels: ,

Monday, January 26, 2009

Krugman Watch

Mr. Krugman writes today in his column about bad-faith arguments against the stimulus plan. Fair enough, there are some bad and even dishonest arguments going around against it. However, he tells us that we should "write...off as a dishonest flack" any person who compares the multi-year cost of the program and the one year estimated jobs effect. Very interesting, since that is exactly what he did back when he was arguing against the Bush tax cuts.

Labels: ,

Friday, January 23, 2009

Yet Again

Not content with merely leaving readers with the mistaken impression that Hoover cut spending, Mr. Krugman now outright lies about it in his Op-Ed from yesterday. Check the real numbers here. This is a key part of his defense of Keynesian economics and the idea that increasing government spending increases prosperity, and it is unequivocally untrue. The man has lost all credibility with me. Can they take back his Nobel?

Labels: , , , ,